Disclaimer:

We are an advocacy group, not a law firm. Information provided is for educational purposes only.

Translate

Is He "Defiant" or Just Bored? The Double Jeopardy of Black Boys



Does this sound like your son?

  • He builds complex Lego structures at home but "can't sit still" at circle time.

  • He asks a million questions about how things work but refuses to do a simple worksheet.

  • He is articulate and funny with you but "aggressive" and "disruptive" at school.

If so, he might not be "bad." He might be Twice Exceptional (2e)—and his boredom is being mistaken for defiance.

The "Twice Exceptional" Trap

Many of the Black boys being pushed out of Gaston County Schools are not lacking in ability; they are overflowing with it.

Twice Exceptional (2e) means a student is Gifted (high intelligence) but also has a disability (like ADHD, Autism, or a learning difference).

  • The Problem: Schools often only see the disability (the behavior), not the gift (the intellect).

  • The Result: When a gifted brain is bored, it seeks stimulation. In a classroom, that looks like "disruption."

    • The boy who taps his pencil is trying to focus.

    • The boy who questions the teacher is trying to engage.

    • The boy who refuses the worksheet is insulting his own intelligence.

Instead of receiving advanced work, these boys receive suspensions.

The "Double Jeopardy" Effect

Why is this boredom treated as a crime? Research from the Yale Child Study Center confirms what Black parents have known for years: Black boys face "Double Jeopardy."

Researchers used eye-tracking technology to watch teachers as they observed a classroom.

  • The Finding: Teachers spent significantly more time watching the Black boy, waiting for misbehavior, than the White boy.

  • The Bias: When researchers showed teachers videos of Black and White actors performing the exact same misbehavior, teachers were significantly more likely to recommend expulsion for the Black boy.

They viewed the White boy’s behavior as "struggling" but the Black boy’s behavior as "blameworthy".

The Real-World Double Standard

This bias plays out every day in our referral forms:

The BehaviorLittle Johnny (White)Little Jamal (Black)
High Energy"He might be gifted or have ADHD. Let's test him.""He is defiant. Send him to the office."
Meltdown"He is overwhelmed. He needs a break.""He is aggressive. He is a safety threat."
Questioning Authority"He is a critical thinker. Leadership material.""He is disrespectful. Insubordinate."

"Black Faces in High Places"

We need to have a hard conversation. This bias exists even in racially diverse schools.

Sometimes, even Black or Brown principals and staff perpetuate this harm. They may feel pressure to "keep the peace" with the district or believe they need to "toughen up" our sons to survive in the world. As the old saying goes, "Black faces in high places do not save us."

Systemic bias is in the policies, not just the people.

Your Defense: The "FBA"

If the school says your child is "acting out," stop the conversation and ask one question: "Is he bored?"

Expecting a child with a disability or exceptionality to operate the same as a standard student without accommodations is like telling a student with asthma to "just breathe harder."

Action Item: Request a Functional Behavioral Assessment (FBA). 

Don't accept the label "Defiant." Defiance is a description, not a diagnosis. You need to know the cause.

Stop the suspension. Start the investigation.


If you believe in this mission and want to help sustain my time and labor, I have set up a way for you to support the work directly.

☕ Buy Me a Coffee: https://buymeacoffee.com/5412founder
💸 CashApp: $BibleBeltBelle

By "buying me a coffee" or sending a CashApp, you are directly funding the labor required to keep this movement alive. Your personal support helps me pay my own bills so I can keep showing up for our families. Thank you for being my village.


#The5412Project #TwiceExceptional #EndTheBias #GastonCountySchools

No comments:

Post a Comment